Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Is Carolina Panthers Wide Receiver Steve Smith A Hall Of Famer?

Before the 2001 NFL Draft teams told Steve Smith that he was to short to play WR in the National Football League.   

The other day Tru School Sports creator, Brendan Taylor, posted a video on YouTube entitled “Is Steve Smith An NFL Hall of Famer?”

At first The Informer read the title and thought Mr. Taylor had lost his mind. Don’t get me wrong, Steve Smith has had a couple of pretty good seasons, but there is no way this guy is a Hall of Famer.

If anything Smith belongs in the hall of very good.

Even though the argument seemed a little ridiculous, as the self proclaimed higher authority on all things NFL wide receivers, The Informer felt it was his duty to watch the video before passing judgement on Smith's career.

Truthfully, it is a good thing The Informer waited to pass judgement, because after the clip he came away thinking that his initial reaction was wrong.

Maybe . . . Just maybe Brendan was on to something here.

It could actually be plausible to say Steve Smith is a future NFL Hall of Fame wide receiver.

Here are the supporting facts:

Currently Smith is in the Top 25 All-Time for receiving yards and moving up.

If Smith can have two or three more years of semi-competent receiver player then it is not inconceivable to think he could move into the Top 10 (He only needs 1,813 yards to pass Henry Ellard for 10th all-time).

Keep in mind the guy is only 34-years-old so three more years at a semi-high level, with Cam Newton as his quarterback, is not totally far-fetched.

Smith also has 818 career receptions, meaning if he retired tomorrow he would finish 26th all-time. However, if he can produce 102 more receptions in his career (At this pace he will add roughly 40 more this season alone) Smith will move into the Top 15 all-time.

Hmm . . . Possible Top 10 in yards and Top 15 in receptions? The Informer is starting to like this idea. 

In 2005, even though the NFL had names like Randy Moss, Larry Fitzgerald, Terrell Owens, Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne and Chad Johnson, Smith led the league in receptions, yards and touchdowns.

To put that in perspective: Since 1990 only Jerry Rice (1990) and Sterling Sharpe (1992) have accomplished the “Triple Crown” for a wide receiver.

Furthermore, Smith achieved his "Triple Crown" despite being the first player since Art Monk in 1984 to lead the league in receptions while playing on a team that ran the ball more than it passed.

Moving along, as a rookie in 2001 Smith became the first punt/kick returner to make the NFL Pro Bowl in eight years. Also during his rookie season the Panthers standout finished with 1,994 total yards (1,795 return yards); which was good enough for the fourth most all-purpose yards in the NFL.

The Informer thinks those two stats are important because it shows Smith was a dynamic football player from day one, adding to his consistency and length of greatness.

In addition to the length of his greatness, it should be noted that Smith was the best player on a Panthers team that made two straight NFC Championship Game appearances and one Super Bowl.

In fact, during the 2003 Playoffs Smith’s 404 yards were the second most ever by a WR (Only 1988 Jerry Rice was better with 409). So, not only was he a dominant regular season player, he stepped his game up and shined in the postseason as well.

Honestly, there is only one real negative argument to keep Smith out of the Hall of Fame: touchdowns. Currently the 13-year veteran has 66 receiving touchdowns while only having one season with more than 10 TD catches (2005).

Don’t get The Informer wrong, 66 is a decent number (Good for 42th all-time by a WR). But we have to remember this is not the hall of decent numbers.

Overall the yards, receptions, special teams contributions and playoff success should outweigh the touchdowns. Nonetheless, for a guy who some would call a borderline Hall of Famer, the lack of end-zone trips could be an issue.

On the other hand, Michael Irvin is in the Hall with fewer touchdowns, receptions and yards than Smith so maybe the lack of touchdowns is a moot point.

As for only having one season with 10+ TD, it turns out of the 21 players ahead of Smith on the all-time receiving yards list; seven off them only had one season of more than 10 TD receptions. Basically the stat doesn't hold near as much weight as The Informer thought it would.

So what is the best “Smith should be in the Hall” argument?

The Informer thinks it is the fact that the Panthers star currently has seven seasons with at least 1,000 yards receiving. For those scoring at home, seven seasons of 1,000 yards is historically good.

Did you know: Only 18 players have ever had at least seven seasons of 1,000 yards?

(The Informer note Fitzgerald, Andre Johnson, Marques Colston and Brandon Marshall can join the group if they reach the 1,000 yard mark this season. Also Detroit Lions star Calvin Johnson just went over the 1,000 yard mark for the sixth time in his career this past weekend.)

The Informer truly thinks seven seasons will be enough for Smith; especially since the majority of those numbers came with “Jake daylight come me want to Delhomme” as his quarterback. However, it sure wouldn’t hurt the cause if the Panthers star added one more 1,000 yard campaign (He has 512 yards this year with six games remaining).

Ultimately the biggest road block in Steve Smith’s chances are the wide receivers ahead of him who are either still waiting to get in, or will be coming up for enshrinement in the next few years.

Andre Reed, Tim Brown, Jimmy Smith, Isaac Bruce, Torry Holt, Hines Ward, Derrick Mason, Marvin Harrison, Randy Moss, Reggie Wayne and Terrell Owens are all going to be looking for their gold jackets in the very near future.

Here is the thing; all of the guys mentioned above actually have better resumes/stats at this time.

Don’t get me wrong stats are not everything, The Informer is just pointing out that there are at least 10 other receivers who will be fighting for the same votes when it comes time for Smith's career to be considered.

The Informer’s point is simple: The so-called log jam for the wide receiver position in the Hall of Fame is real. Just look at last year when only three receivers even made the final 15 (five guys are enshrined each year).

Of the three, Chris Carter was the only one selected. Now keep in mind when Carter retired he was Top 10 in receiving yards, receptions and touchdowns; yet he still had to wait six years to get his name called.

So while The Informer’s mind has been changed and he now feels Smith is definitely Canton worthy, the reality of the situation is it could be an uphill climb.

Then again, when Smith does retire, he will have the Carolina’s franchise record for receptions, receiving yards and touchdowns while holding the title of the greatest Panthers player in team history (Cam Newton’s application pending of course).

Just saying, if the NFL HOF is a representation of each of its 32 team’s history; then it would not be justifiable to leave out one the teams greatest player –right?

Final verdict: It is going to take a couple of years, but eventually Smith will be recognized and enshrined into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.


1. Jerry Rice: 14 1,000 yard seasons and nine with 10+ TDs

2. Randy Moss: 10 1,000 yard seasons and nine with 10+ TDs

3. Terrell Owens: nine 1,000 yard seasons and eight with 10+ TDs

4. Jimmy Smith: nine 1,000 yard seasons (zero 10+ TDs)

5. Marvin Harrison: eight 1,000 yard seasons and eight with 10+ TDs

6. Chris Carter: eight 1,000 yard seasons and eight with 10+ TDs

7. Reggie Wayne: eight 1,000 yard seasons and three with 10+ TDs

8. Torry Holt: eight 1,000 yard seasons and three with 10+ TDs

9. Isaac Bruce: eight 1,000 yard seasons and two with 10+ TDs

10. Derrick Mason: eight 1,000 yard seasons (Zero with 10+ TDs)

11. Tim Brown: eight 1,000 yard seasons and two with 10+ TDs

12. Lance Alsworth: seven 1,000 yard seasons and five with 1-+ TDs

13. Rod Smith: seven 1,000 yard seasons and two with 10+ TDs

14. Michael Irvin: seven 1,000 yard seasons and one with 10+ TDs

15. Steve Smith: seven 1,000 yard seasons and one with 10+ TDs

16. Henry Ellard: seven 1,000 yards seasons and one with 10+ TDs

17. Chad “Ochocinco” Johnson: seven 1,000 yard seasons and one with 10+ TDs

18. Donald Driver: seven 1,000 yard seasons (Zero with 10+ TDs)

1 comment:

  1. Could not possibly agree with you more. Smitty will get into the hall of fame but it won't be in the first year he is eligible. He has been an impact player since the time he entered the league. Can you imagine how good he would be if he had the size of Megatron! Would it be safe to say he was the best receiver in history under 5'10"?


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...